Why the ‘Protect Our Neighbors Act’ Amnesty Proposal Would Backfire

A better name would be the ‘Law of Unintended Consequences’, because that’s what it would ensure

By Andrew R. Arthur on November 20, 2026

On November 18, ABC News reported that Rep. Lateefah Simon (D-Calif.) will be introducing a bill called the “Protect Our Neighbors Act” (PONA) that would put a 10-year time expiration date on orders of removal. If the text of that bill is anything like it has been described, you might as well call it the “Law of Unintended Consequences”, because that’s what it would ensure.

“House Dems to Introduce Immigration Bill”

The ABC News article is headlined “House Dems to introduce immigration bill establishing a 10-year expiration on final orders of removal”, and it apparently is also being championed by three of Rep. Simon’s fellow California Democratic representatives: Zoe Lofgren, John Garamendi, and Juan Vargas.

The article explains the bill “was shared first with ABC News”, but it would have been helpful if the outlet had seen fit to share it with the rest of us, too, so we could figure out what it says. As is, I have only their description to go on.

In any event, here’s what ABC News claims PONA does:

Under this proposal, final orders of removal would expire 10 years after they were issued for individuals who have been continuously present in the U.S. and have not been convicted of a crime. As of now, there is no expiration on final orders of removal.

The bill would allow an immigration judge to renew an expired final order of removal if it was established by "clear and convincing evidence" that there was significant cause for the delay in executing a final order unrelated to administrative or funding delays and renewal of the order is in the public interest based on new evidence, according to the bill's text.

…

The legislation would also create a pathway to lawful permanent residency for individuals with expired orders of removal.

My Notes on a Bill I Haven’t Seen

There’s a lot to unpack there, so here are my notes on this bill that I haven’t actually seen.

First, let’s call it what it is, an “amnesty”, because it requires the American people to “forgive and forget”: forget that the alien received due process and a final removal order; and apparently forgive the alien’s illegal presence in this country for a decade or more.

Moving to the end, “lawful permanent residency” apparently refers to “lawful permanent resident” (LPR) status, commonly known as a “green card”, but it’s not clear whether the 10-year deadline would automatically lead to a green card, or rather would allow an alien to then apply for another form of “relief” from USCIS or in immigration court that could lead to a green card, or if there is some other waiting period (or requirements) for a green card.

Moving up, it’s not clear how a renewal request would make it to an immigration judge to begin with, and who would make it.

Presumably, after 10 years DHS would be forced to return to immigration court to ask for renewal of the removal order, at which point the department would be required to show by “clear and convincing evidence” that it didn’t or couldn’t remove the alien for more than a decade due to some reason other than “administrative or funding delays”.

As the Legal Information Institute (LII) explains, the “clear and convincing evidence” standard “is a medium level burden of proof” that “is more rigorous to meet than preponderance of the evidence standard, but a less rigorous standard to meet than proving evidence beyond a reasonable doubt”.

Why PONA’s sponsors chose that particularly rigorous standard is unclear, but in any event a non-enforcement friendly Congress could essentially trigger that 10-year amnesty by either not funding ICE (a “funding delay”) or by underfunding it and causing an “administrative delay”.

Similarly, an enforcement-hostile administration could induce the amnesty by imposing onerous and nonsensical restrictions on ICE (an administrative delay) or by deliberately asking Congress for less money than the agency needs (a funding delay), both of which occurred under the Biden administration.

As I have explained repeatedly in the past, DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas effectively hobbled ICE’s ability to arrest aliens under final removal orders — and criminal aliens in particular — with his September 30, 2021, “Guidelines for the Enforcement of Civil Immigration Law” (the “Mayorkas memo”).

Under the Mayorkas memo, ICE officers could not undertake any “enforcement action” — investigating, questioning, arresting, prosecuting, or deporting any criminal alien — unless immigration officers and attorneys first considered a list of irrelevant “aggravating” and “mitigating” factors.

Among the aggravating factors were the crime in question, its recency, and its seriousness, which some may argue was fair game with “limited resources” on the line.

But there was no justification for the mitigating factors, which included: the alien’s “advanced or tender age” and “lengthy presence in the United States”; any “mental condition that may have contributed to the criminal conduct”; “evidence of rehabilitation”; and even “public service of the [alien] and their immediate family”.

Thus, a 65-year-old convicted child sex offender with an antisocial personality disorder diagnosis (i.e., a “sociopath”) who’d been living here illegally since he was 20 with a daughter who works at the post office and who is seeking redemption by coaching little league baseball and volunteering at the church youth group would likely be off-limits for removal.

That’s why, as ABC News reported, “there were about 1.6 million people” in the United States who had “final deportation orders” as of this February: The Biden administration removed only a fraction of aliens who had final removal orders, and criminals in particular, forcing Trump II to play catch up ever since.

Biden also attempted to curb ICE funding, for example by asking Congress in his 2023 budget request to cut immigration detention beds by roughly a quarter (to 25,000 beds from 34,000 beds then funded) at a time that more than two million aliens were pouring over the Southwest border illegally.

Pro tip: Most aliens must be detained before they can be removed, so the fewer detention beds, the fewer deportations.

Motions to Reopen

Keep in mind through all of this that an alien under a final removal order — for a day or 30 years — could potentially already move to reopen his final removal order.

According to the latest DOJ statistics, nearly 83,000 such motions were filed with immigration judges and an additional 12,243 with the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) — more than 95,000 in total and a population larger than Santa Fe, N.M., or Duluth, Minn. — in FY 2025 and through the first nine months of FY 2026.

Under section 240(c)(7) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA), an alien may only file one motion to reopen, and that motion must “state the new facts that will be proven at a hearing to be held if the motion is granted”.

Moreover, while a motion to reopen must generally be filed within 90 days of the date the removal order became administratively final (when no appeal was filed with the BIA or an appeal was filed and the BIA dismissed it), that deadline is extended indefinitely “if the basis of the motion is to apply for” asylum under section 208 of the INA or withholding of removal under section 241(b)(3) of the INA (“statutory withholding”).

In that instance, the new asylum or statutory withholding claim must be “based on changed country conditions arising in the country of nationality or the country to which removal has been ordered”, and the alien must present material evidence with the motion that “was not available and would not have been discovered or presented at the previous proceeding”.

Given that political conditions around the world change constantly, that’s often not a high bar to clear.

In addition, if the removal order was issued in absentia when the alien failed to appear in immigration court (and 58 percent of the 476,650 removal orders issued in the first three quarters of FY 2026 were issued in absentia), the deadline for filing a motion to reopen is also extended indefinitely if the alien can show he did not receive proper notice of the hearing.

The Immigration Multiplier Effect

Again, because the PONA bill language has not been introduced, there’s no way to know how the green card provision therein would work. But if proponents of that bill claim it would only apply to “X number of aliens”, be ready to double, triple, or quadruple (or more) that total.

That’s because of the immigration “multiplier” effect my colleague Jessica Vaughan described in September 2017. Here’s how it works.

As Vaughan explained, “Initiating immigrants can sponsor spouses and children as soon as they have permanent residency,” which means that if a PONA green card alien is married or has kids, those aliens immediately become eligible to seek green cards, as well.

And as soon as PONA green card holders become U.S. citizens — and section 316 of the INA permits LPRs to apply to naturalize after five years — they can “sponsor their parents or siblings from abroad”, too.

Parents of U.S. citizens are admitted in unlimited numbers, boosting the total even more, and while siblings are subject to annual caps, the new PONA-eligible brothers and sisters would significantly exacerbate the nearly 2.2 million case backlog of foreign nationals abroad awaiting family “fourth preference” visas as of November 2023, the last time the State Department published totals.

And once those new second-generation PONA aliens get LPR status, the whole process starts again, à la the Heather Locklear 1984 “Fabergé Organics” shampoo commercial (“and they told two friends, and they told two friends, and so on, and so on”).

No permanent immigration benefit is granted in a vacuum, unless the terms of that benefit limit it solely to primary beneficiaries, which I seriously doubt the ostensibly unserious PONA does.

The Biggest Unintended Consequence

Then, there’s the biggest unintended consequence of PONA: If this bill became law, every final removal order would come with a 10-year “arrest and removal” clock.

Opponents of ICE enforcement under Trump II complain that immigration officers aren’t going after the “worst of the worst”, but that argument only makes sense (to the degree it makes any sense at all) if ICE has the resources and authority to focus initially on the most hardened of criminals and to worry about the rest of the illegal population later — a “worst first” strategy.

If PONA made its way to the Rose Garden, ICE would be forced to adopt an “oldest first” strategy that targeted aliens with removal orders on the verge of expiring regardless of their criminal records.

In fact, because this proposal explicitly indicts ICE for not making removals in a timely manner, it implicitly tells the agency to direct its energies toward finding and deporting aliens with the oldest removal orders first or risk losing the authority to deport those aliens at all.

Had the immigration hawks in the “Mass Deportation Coalition” (MDC) tried to write a bill to force the president to “fulfill his signature campaign promise to ‘conduct the largest mass deportation operation in American history’” (their stated goal) , they could hardly have done a better, or more effective, job.

“A Strong Public Interest in Bringing Litigation to a Close”

In the mid-1980s, the Supreme Court issued three opinions, INS v. Rios-Pineda, INS v. Abudu, and INS v. Doherty, that narrowed aliens’ ability to delay their deportations indefinitely through motions to reopen.

In Abudu, the justices explained: “There is a strong public interest in bringing litigation to a close as promptly as is consistent with the interest in giving the adversaries a fair opportunity to develop and present their respective cases.”

Aliens under final removal orders have, by definition, received all the “due process” rights to which they are entitled, but PONA would subvert that “strong public interest in bringing litigation to a close” in three ways.

First, it would create a “catch me if you can” regime that would allow aliens to “run out the clock” and receive by purportedly remedial statute that which they were unable to secure through litigation.

Second, and relatedly, unless PONA automatically gives a green card to every alien under a final removal order at the 10-year mark (which would be fraught with its own issues and unintended consequences), it will inevitably lead to more litigation, as PONA beneficiaries seek the new benefit, some or many through fraud.

Third, and apparently by design, it would require DHS to engage in new rounds of litigation to show it couldn’t deport aliens within 10 years for reasons having nothing to do with “funding or administrative” delays.

Then there’s the dictum the Court established in Doherty: “every delay works to the advantage of the deportable alien who wishes merely to remain in the United States”.

Respectfully, there’s no reason for Congress to create yet more incentives for delays that only “work to the advantage of the deportable alien” and provide no benefit to the American people whom the INA is ultimately designed to serve.

“Act in Haste, Regret in Leisure”

Congress should think long and hard about the (as yet unseen) “Protect Our Neighbors Act”, because it would apparently upend long-held immigration principles, exacerbate already long wait times for legal visas, and force ICE to abandon any “worst of the worst” deportation strategy to instead target aliens with the oldest removal orders. Unintended consequences, indeed.