The H-1B Tsunami: Why the U.S. Must Act to Protect American Jobs, Security, and Prosperity

Listen to "‘Industrialized’ Fraud in the H-1B Visa Program" on Spreaker.

Listen to a Podcast interview of Mahvash Siddiqui

Twenty years ago, I served as one of 15 junior visa officers at the U.S. Consulate in Chennai, India — the H-1B visa fraud capital of the world. We adjudicated thousands of visas daily in an environment where 70–90 percent of applicants sought to exploit the nonimmigrant visa system to live and work in the U.S. illegally. While we could reject most fraudulent applications, H-1Bs were different: They came pre-approved by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), making denials rare (~2 percent). Revocations required laborious after-hours legal memos — work few had time for while processing 200 visas a day.

H-1B visas became the perfect loophole for many Indian nationals aged 20–45 to enter the U.S. with fraudulent or inflated credentials, displacing qualified American IT and STEM workers. From 2005–2007, Chennai adjudicated ~100,000 H-1Bs annually. Today, demand has exploded to 400,000-plus per year.

Fraud and Corruption in the System

Fraud was industrialized. In Ameerpet, Hyderabad, entire markets sold fake degrees, forged bank statements, and counterfeit marriage/birth certificates. Many H-1Bs claiming computer science degrees had no related coursework or programming skills; basic coding tests often exposed them. Corrupt HR officials in both India and the U.S. facilitated fake employment letters, allowing underqualified candidates to bypass scrutiny.

A pervasive “halo effect” favored Indian applicants, compounded by bribery (“rishwat”) and cultural normalization of fraud. In the U.S., some Indian managers created insular hiring networks, excluding Americans, protecting unqualified hires, and fostering “honor among thieves” environments that discouraged whistleblowing. American IT graduates — trained through rigorous programs — were left unemployed or were forced to train their H-1B replacements for lower pay.

F-1 and J-1 Visas: Extended Access to U.S. Opportunities

The issue extends beyond IT. Indian medical graduates — many admitted to schools via affirmative action or bribery — enter U.S. residency programs on J-1 visas, ultimately practicing medicine here with lower skill levels than American-trained physicians.

Similarly, F-1 visas allow international students to pursue academic studies in the U.S., often in elite Ivy League and other top universities. Many F-1 students later leverage Optional Practical Training (OPT) and H-1B visas to remain in the U.S., often being guided into IT companies via Indian networks.

USCIS site inspections are minimal, providing little assurance of compliance despite hundreds of thousands of active petitions.

Silicon Valley, Nepotism, and Wage Reality

Indian lobbyists and Silicon Valley have pushed a disinformation campaign portraying American workers as less capable, masking the displacement of domestic talent and the transfer of intellectual property abroad. Congress, often naive to these realities, has been misled.

Wage Reality: H-1Bs vs. American Professionals

Contrary to the narrative that H-1Bs accept lower wages, data reveals that H-1B workers often earn equal to or more than U.S. workers in the same roles:

In Silicon Valley, Indian-origin managers and executives frequently favor hiring fellow Indian H-1B visa holders, creating barriers for American workers and fostering ethnic preference. Companies like Microsoft filed thousands of H-1B petitions (6,327 in 2025, 78 percent of which were for Indian nationals) even while laying off over 9,000 employees, raising concerns about displacement of U.S. workers.

Indian H-1Bs are also employed at U.S. government contractor facilities. While some are properly vetted, many gain access to sensitive information and critical systems, often unchecked, creating potential national security and cybersecurity risks.

There is plenty of evidence of abuse, including:

• “Infosys to settle US visa fraud case for $34M”
• “Tech Staffing Firm Pleads Guilty to H-1B Fraud”
• “Tracy California resident convicted on multiple counts of ‘H-1B’ visa fraud, aggravated identity theft”

Conclusion

The H-1B program, conceived to fill genuine skill shortages, has morphed into a de facto immigration shortcut dominated by one country. It is riddled with fraud and corrosive to U.S. labor markets, national security, and economic welfare. An America-First approach demands restoring fairness, enforcing our laws, and ensuring that American workers and students — not foreign networks — reap the benefits of U.S. opportunity.

Policy Recommendations

• Pause new H-1B issuances pending a full program audit.
• Strengthen vetting — verify degrees, skills, and employment history rigorously.
• Prioritize U.S. STEM graduates for hiring in sectors with available talent.
• Ban nepotistic/chain hiring practices that exclude Americans.
• Enforce penalties for fraud — recent prosecutions prove deterrence is possible.
• Expand site inspections to match program scale and risk.

Disclaimer: This article is not biased against India or Indian professionals. The intent is to address structural issues in U.S. visa programs, labor markets, and hiring practices, while highlighting the impact on American workers and national security. The observations are based on documented patterns and systemic practices, not nationality or ethnicity. An earlier version of this article was published by the Ben Franklin Fellowship.